Top 16 Elden Ring Items That Only Appear After Certain Choices
One of the most intriguing aspects of Elden Ring is how your decisions shape not only the story but also the world itself—sometimes in subtle, easily missed ways. Certain Elden Ring Items don’t spawn until specific choices are made, and many players can go through an entire playthrough without ever discovering them.
If you're planning a new build or diving into New Game Plus, these 16 items are worth watching out for. Some are tied to questline outcomes, while others require unique interactions or deliberate character decisions. Understanding where these items come from can give your builds more depth—or at the very least, give you more reasons to explore every corner of the Lands Between.
Here’s a guide to 16 items that only become available after making particular choices in the game.
1. Dung Eater Puppet (Spirit Ash)
To get this unique summon, you’ll need to progress Ranni’s questline and offer Seluvis’s potion to Dung Eater instead of Nepheli or Gideon. This locks you out of other endings but grants a powerful, tanky summon.
2. Morgott’s Cursed Sword
Only available after defeating Morgott and trading his Remembrance. But if you choose to use the Remembrance for runes instead, you lose access to this weapon permanently—one of the few choices that directly blocks an item.
3. Fia’s Champion Set
You must side with Fia and complete her quest through Deeproot Depths. Only then will the set become available near her body after she dies. Skipping her quest or giving her the wrong items means missing it entirely.
4. Millicent’s Prosthesis
After helping Millicent defeat her sisters, you must kill her at the end of the fight to claim the item. If you choose to assist her instead, you’ll get a different reward. It’s a rare example of mutually exclusive Elden Ring Items tied to your moral choice.
5. Seluvis’s Puppet Collection
By choosing to dig deeper into Seluvis’s secret lab and siding with him, you unlock the chance to get puppets like Dolores the Sleeping Arrow. Rejecting his creepy ambitions cuts this option off entirely.
6. Nepheli’s Stormhawk King
This ash item can only be obtained if you go out of your way to explore the Chapel of Anticipation via a teleporter in late-game. Give it to Nepheli to unlock her best ending, but it won’t even exist unless you return to a starting area most players forget about.
7. Latenna’s Spirit Ash
Only unlocked by choosing to follow Albus’s dying wish and carrying the Haligtree medallion to Latenna. Skipping the conversation or going to the Haligtree via a different route means you’ll never meet her.
8. Brother Corhyn’s Robes
These only drop after finishing Goldmask’s ending and returning to Corhyn’s final resting place. If you ignore the quest or pursue a different ending, the robes simply don’t appear.
9. Rogier’s Rapier +8
You’ll only receive this weapon if you speak to Rogier after defeating the Black Knife Assassin in the Limgrave catacombs. Progressing too far without returning to him causes him to die without ever giving you the item.
10. Beast Claw Greathammer
You’ll have to choose to fully complete Gurranq’s side quest by feeding him all the Deathroot. Once he recovers and regains control, he rewards you with this weapon. Miss any steps, and you miss out.
11. Talisman Pouch (Third Slot)
Granted by either killing Godfrey (first shade version) or receiving it from the Twin Maiden Husks, depending on how you progress the main story. The choice of route determines whether it’s available earlier or later.
12. Black Knife Tiche
Only appears if you complete Ranni’s full questline and defeat Alecto, Black Knife Ringleader. If you abandon the quest or choose a different ending path, Tiche remains locked away.
13. Lionel’s Set
This heavy armor set only appears near Fia’s chamber after progressing her quest to a specific point. If you arrive too early or too late, it may not be there depending on how the world state has changed.
14. Rya’s Necklace
After confronting Blackguard Big Boggart and either helping him or fighting him, this key item appears. It’s essential for advancing Rya’s story, but if you kill him or ignore the encounter, her quest may stall.
15. Boltdrake Talisman +2
Only appears in Farum Azula after specific events in the main story are triggered. Speedrunning or sequence-breaking the area might prevent it from spawning altogether.
16. Malenia’s Hand and Waterfowl Dance
Only obtainable by defeating Malenia and trading her Remembrance. However, you must choose between the Hand and her katana. If you use the Remembrance for runes or choose the wrong one, there’s no going back unless you duplicate the Remembrance—a rare option in itself.
Elden Ring thrives on the consequences of your decisions, and that extends well beyond endings or character arcs. Some of the most powerful and interesting Elden Ring Items are tied to specific narrative or world choices—often with no second chance if you miss them.
If you're experimenting with new characters or builds, tracking these conditional items can offer a fresh layer of depth. For those looking to streamline builds or test out high-end equipment sooner, some players prefer to buy elden ring runes to help speed up the process and focus on exploration rather than farming.
In a game where every decision carries weight, it pays to know which items are locked behind your choices. Whether you’re chasing powerful gear or just trying to uncover every secret, these 16 items are a perfect reason to replay Elden Ring with fresh eyes.